Lovegrove knows his Holmes trivia and delivers a great mystery that will fans will enjoy, with plenty of winks and nods to the canon. - Geek Dad A satisfying book, wrapping up to a fascinating conclusion. - Fangirl Nation A good yarn of a read for any Sherlock fans - Retrenders Lovegrove manages to perfectly emulate Doyle's (or Watson's, if you will), style, while at the same time playing up the most important and interesting aspect of the Canon: the relationship between Holmes and Watson. - Cinema Sentries