WIN $150 GIFT VOUCHERS: ALADDIN'S GOLD

Close Notification

Your cart does not contain any items

Supreme Hubris

How Overconfidence Is Destroying the Court—and How We Can Fix It

Aaron Tang

$51.95

Hardback

Not in-store but you can order this
How long will it take?

QTY:

English
Yale University Press
22 December 2023
How to repair the dysfunction at the Supreme Court in a way that cuts across partisan ideologies

 

The Supreme Court, once the most respected institution in American government, is now routinely criticized for rendering decisions based on the individual justices’ partisan leanings rather than on a faithful reading of the law. For legal scholar Aaron Tang, however, partisanship is not the Court’s root problem. Overconfidence is.

 

Conservative and liberal justices alike have adopted a tone of uncompromising certainty in their ability to solve society’s problems with just the right lawyerly arguments. The result is a Court that lurches stridently from one case to the next, delegitimizing opposing views and undermining public confidence in itself. 

 

To restore the Court’s legitimacy, Tang proposes a different approach to hard cases: a “least harm principle” under which the Court rules against the side with the greatest ability to avoid the harm it would suffer in defeat. Examining a surprising number of popular opinions where the Court has applied this approach, Tang shows how the least harm principle can provide a promising and legally grounded framework for the difficult cases that divide our nation.
By:  
Imprint:   Yale University Press
Country of Publication:   United States
Dimensions:   Height: 216mm,  Width: 140mm, 
ISBN:   9780300264036
ISBN 10:   0300264038
Pages:   328
Publication Date:  
Audience:   Professional and scholarly ,  Undergraduate
Format:   Hardback
Publisher's Status:   Active

Aaron Tang is professor at the University of California, Davis, School of Law and a former law clerk to Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor. His writings have appeared in the New York Times, Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, and Slate.

Reviews for Supreme Hubris: How Overconfidence Is Destroying the Court—and How We Can Fix It

Tang masterfully shows how overconfidence bias among U.S. Supreme Court justices has imperiled this once hallowed institution. A must read on where the Court went wrong, and how to fix it. -Franita Tolson, author of In Congress We Trust?: Enforcing Voting Rights from the Founding to the Jim Crow Era Tang's important book explains that the Supreme Court's errors often stem from its overconfidence. He offers an innovative solution: justices should pursue the outcome that is likely to cause the least harm. -Erwin Chemerinsky, author of Worse than Nothing: The Dangerous Fallacy of Originalism Aaron Tang has accomplished something extraordinary. He has written a smart and original book about how the Supreme Court should do its job. It is almost impossible to say something truly new about constitutional law that makes a contribution. Tang has done that with his least harm principle. -Eric Segall, author of Originalism as Faith


See Also